How to Make Plant-Based Protein Powder Taste Better

Apr 03, 2024Contributing Editor

Are you tired of the bland taste of your plant-based protein powder? Wondering how to make it more enjoyable without compromising its nutritional benefits? In this article, we'll explore various strategies to enhance the flavor of your plant-based protein shakes. From incorporating fresh fruits to experimenting with spices and adding unique ingredients like nut butter and extracts, we'll guide you through creative ways to elevate the taste of your protein-packed drinks. 

Blend with Fruits

Protein shakes are a convenient way to boost protein intake, but the taste can be bland.  Adding fruits deliciously tackles this problem. Here’s how: 

  • Enhance Flavor and Sweetness: Fruits naturally contain sugars like fructose, which adds sweetness to your shake. They also have acids like citric acid, that can add a tangy taste that complements the flavor of protein powder.
  • Add Important Nutrients: Fruits are loaded with vitamins, minerals, and fiber. For instance, they are a good source of Vitamin C, A, potassium, and fiber.
  • Provide Antioxidants: Many fruits are rich in antioxidants, which can help protect your cells from damage.
  • Create a Thicker Consistency: If you prefer a thicker shake, fruits can help you achieve that without adding unhealthy thickeners.

Incorporating a variety of fruits into your diet is an essential component of a balanced and healthy lifestyle. Fruits provide a multitude of essential vitamins, minerals, and dietary fiber, all crucial for optimal bodily function. Here's a selection of some highly recommended fruits, each with a brief description of their key nutritional value:

  • Citrus fruits (oranges, grapefruits, lemons, and limes): Renowned for their exceptional vitamin C content, citrus fruits play a vital role in immune system health and collagen production.
  • Berries (blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, and blackberries): These potent sources of antioxidants offer significant protection against cellular damage, potentially reducing the risk of chronic diseases.
  • Melons (watermelon, cantaloupe, and honeydew melon):  Melons boast a high water content, making them excellent for hydration, while also providing essential vitamins A and C.
  • Tropical fruits (mango, pineapple, papaya, and kiwi):  A treasure trove of vitamins and minerals, tropical fruits offer a unique and diverse range of micronutrients often lacking in standard diets.
  • Stone fruits (peaches, plums, nectarines, and cherries):  Stone fruits are a valuable source of dietary fiber, promoting digestive health, alongside offering a good amount of vitamin C for immune function.
  • Bananas:  A convenient source of readily available energy, bananas are rich in potassium, a mineral crucial for proper muscle and nerve function.
  • Apples:  A versatile and readily available fruit, apples are a good source of dietary fiber, promoting gut health, and vitamin C, vital for immune function.

Use Nut Butters

While often viewed as a simple flavoring agent, nut butter offers a multitude of functional benefits when incorporated into protein shakes. Let's explore how nut butter can elevate your protein shake from a basic beverage to a well-rounded nutritional powerhouse:

  • Nutritional Boost: Nut butter is packed with nutrients, particularly protein, and healthy fats. Adding a spoonful or two to your shake can significantly increase its protein content, which is crucial for muscle building, repair, and satiety. Healthy fats from nut butter also contribute to a feeling of fullness and slow down the absorption of sugar, keeping you feeling energized for longer.
  • Creamy Texture: Nut butter acts as a natural thickener in your shake, creating a rich and creamy consistency. This is especially beneficial if you're using watery fruits or bases like milk or water.
  • Flavor Depth: Nut butter introduces a new dimension of flavor to your shake.  Depending on the nut butter you choose, you can add a variety of delicious notes – peanut butter offers a classic nutty flavor, almond butter adds a richer depth, and cashew butter provides a creamier and more subtle taste. You can even experiment with unique nut butters like pistachio or macadamia for a truly gourmet shake.

Add Natural Sweeteners

While refined sugar reigns supreme in many kitchens, natural sweeteners have emerged as a tempting alternative. But are they truly healthier? Let's delve into the potential benefits of natural sweeteners and explore why honey, maple syrup, and agave nectar might be enticing options compared to refined sugar.

Natural Sweeteners: A More Nuanced Approach to Sweetness

Natural sweeteners aren't just about satisfying your sweet tooth. Unlike refined sugar, some natural options, like honey and maple syrup, boast small amounts of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. While the quantities might be modest, they offer a slight edge over refined sugar's purely caloric contribution.

For those managing blood sugar levels or seeking sustained energy, certain natural sweeteners can be game-changers. Stevia and monk fruit extract, for example, have a very low glycemic index (GI), meaning they cause a slower rise in blood sugar compared to refined sugar. This translates to a more balanced approach to sweetness, avoiding the sugar crash often associated with refined sugars.

Beyond the health considerations, natural sweeteners unlock a world of flavor exploration. Honey's floral notes, maple syrup's distinct caramel essence, and dates' subtle fruitiness elevate the taste profile of your food and beverages, adding a layer of complexity that refined sugar simply can't match.

Why Choose Honey, Maple Syrup, or Agave Nectar?

While not without drawbacks (see below), honey, maple syrup, and agave nectar offer some advantages over refined sugar:

  • Less Processed: These natural sweeteners undergo less processing compared to refined white sugar, which may appeal to those seeking a more natural approach to their diet.
  • Flavor Variety: As mentioned previously, each of these sweeteners brings its unique flavor profile to the table, adding depth and complexity to your food or drink.


Experiment with Spices

Shakes, especially protein shakes, can sometimes fall flat on the taste bud front.  Spices can be a great way to add complexity and interest to your shake!

Here's how spices can enhance your shake:

  • Add new dimensions of flavor: Spices can introduce new taste profiles like warm, earthy, or even a touch of heat. This can complement the base flavor of your shake, like chocolate or fruit, and make it more interesting.
  • Boost other flavors: Certain spices can enhance the flavors already present in your shake. For instance, cinnamon can make chocolate taste richer, while nutmeg can brighten up fruit flavors.

Now, let's explore some spices to experiment with:

  • Classics: Cinnamon, nutmeg, and even a pinch of ground ginger are all fantastic options for adding warmth and complexity to shakes, especially those with chocolate, banana, or pumpkin flavors.
  • For a kick: A tiny pinch of cayenne pepper or a dash of black pepper can add a surprising and delightful twist to shakes, especially fruit-based ones.
  • Exotic flair: Cardamom, with its floral and slightly citrusy notes, can be amazing in mango or pineapple shakes. A touch of saffron can add a luxurious touch and subtle honey-like flavor.

Blend with Non-Dairy Milk

The versatility of shakes extends beyond traditional dairy-based recipes. Non-dairy milk alternatives have become increasingly popular for a variety of reasons, offering both functional and flavorful benefits.

There are a couple of reasons why people choose non-dairy milk for shakes:

  • Lactose intolerance or dairy allergy:  Lactose intolerance means your body has trouble digesting lactose, the sugar found in milk. Dairy allergies are more serious immune system reactions to milk protein. Non-dairy milk offers a delicious alternative for people with either condition.
  • Vegan diet: Vegans avoid all animal products, including milk.  Non-dairy milk provides a way to enjoy shakes and other beverages without compromising their dietary choices.
  • Taste preference: Some people simply prefer the taste of non-dairy milk.  This is a matter of personal preference, of course!

Now, let's look at how each milk option affects your shake:

  • Almond milk: This has a mild, nutty flavor and a thin consistency. It blends well in smoothies without overpowering other flavors and keeps the calorie count down since it's naturally low in calories and fat.
  • Coconut milk:  Coconut milk has a richer, sweeter taste and a thicker texture than other plant-based milk.  It can be a great choice for tropical-flavored shakes or if you want a thicker, creamier consistency. Be aware that coconut milk is higher in calories and fat than other options.
  • Oat milk: Oat milk has a naturally sweet and creamy texture, making it a good choice for creating a milkshake-like texture. It also froths well, which can be nice for a fancy coffee shop-style drink. Oat milk does have a slightly higher carb content than some other options.


Include Yogurt or Non-Dairy Yogurt

Yogurt, both dairy and its non-dairy counterparts, is a popular ingredient in shakes, offering functional benefits that significantly impact the final product's texture and flavor profile. Understanding how yogurt interacts with other shake components allows for the creation of more balanced and enjoyable beverages.

One of the primary benefits of yogurt in shakes is its contribution to creaminess. This creamy texture arises from two key functionalities of yogurt:

  • Emulsification: Yogurt's natural protein content plays a crucial role in emulsifying the shake's ingredients. Proteins act as emulsifiers by stabilizing the mixture of water-based and oil-based components, preventing separation and creating a smooth, homogenous texture.
  • Thickening: The inherent thickness of yogurt, particularly Greek yogurt which has undergone whey removal, naturally thickens the shake. This results in a more substantial and satisfying mouthfeel compared to thinner, purely liquid-based beverages. Non-dairy yogurts often achieve similar thickening properties through the use of ingredients like coconut cream or various starches.

There are many yogurt and non-dairy yogurt options available, each offering slightly different textures and flavors. Here's a breakdown of some popular choices:

Dairy Yogurt:

  • Plain Yogurt: This versatile option offers a mild, tangy flavor that can be customized with fruits, granola, honey, or other toppings.
  • Greek Yogurt: Strained to remove whey, Greek yogurt boasts a thicker consistency and higher protein content compared to regular yogurt. Its tanginess can be slightly more pronounced than plain yogurt.
  • Skyr: This Icelandic yogurt is similar to Greek yogurt in thickness and protein content but with a slightly less tart flavor.

Non-Dairy Yogurt:

  • Coconut Yogurt: Made from coconut milk, this yogurt offers a naturally sweet and creamy texture with a subtle coconut flavor.
  • Almond Milk Yogurt: This plant-based yogurt has a mild almond flavor and a thinner consistency than some other non-dairy options.
  • Oat Milk Yogurt: Made with oat milk, this yogurt has a creamy texture and a very subtle oat flavor.
  • Soy Yogurt: A good source of protein, soy yogurt has a slightly sweet flavor and a smooth texture.


Mix with Coffee or Matcha

The realm of shakes extends beyond the classic combination of fruits and yogurt. Coffee and matcha offer exciting possibilities for those seeking functional benefits and unique flavor profiles. These ingredients not only provide a delightful caffeine boost but also introduce distinct taste characteristics that can be further accentuated through creative experimentation.

Coffee's integration into shakes offers a familiar flavor and an invigorating energy boost.  Here are two primary methods for incorporating coffee:

  • Brewed Coffee or Cold Brew Concentrate: Utilizing leftover brewed coffee or a cold brew concentrate represents the simplest and most efficient approach. This method adds the classic coffee taste and a dose of caffeine without introducing additional preparation steps. Begin with a minimal amount of coffee, gradually increasing the quantity to achieve your desired level of coffee intensity.
  • Coffee Powder:  For a more pronounced coffee flavor, espresso powder or finely ground coffee beans can be used. However, these options may result in a textural issue with slight grittiness. Ensure thorough blending at a high speed to achieve a smooth consistency.


Flavor Twists with Coffee

Coffee's inherent bitterness lends itself well to a variety of complementary flavor combinations that can enhance the overall taste experience:

  • Mocha Marvel: Combining coffee with chocolate creates a beloved mocha flavor. Experiment with chocolate syrup, cocoa powder, or even chocolate protein powder for an added protein punch. This combination not only complements the coffee bitterness but also creates a richer and more decadent beverage.
  • Caramel Comfort: Coffee pairs beautifully with caramel, offering a familiar and comforting taste experience. Include caramel sauce, drizzle, or even chopped candy bars for a delightful twist. The sweetness of the caramel effectively balances the coffee's bitterness, creating a more balanced and enjoyable beverage.
  • Banana Blitz: The unexpected yet delicious marriage of coffee and banana creates an energizing and flavorful shake. Banana adds natural sweetness and creaminess, effectively counteracting the coffee's bitterness. This combination provides a potassium boost alongside the caffeine content, making it a more functional choice for athletes or those seeking sustained energy.

Add Cocoa or Cacao Powder

Cocoa and cacao powder are the cornerstones of chocolatey shakes. While they offer a similar taste profile, some key distinctions influence their impact on your shake. Here's a breakdown of their roles and how they create that delicious chocolate flavor:

Cocoa and Cacao: Processing Matters

  • Cocoa Powder: This widely used powder is the result of roasting cocoa beans, removing some of the fat (cocoa butter), and grinding the remaining solids. This process mellows the flavor and reduces bitterness compared to raw cacao powder.  Dutch-processed cocoa powder is further treated to neutralize its acidity, resulting in an even smoother taste.
  • Cacao Powder:  This powder is minimally processed, with the cocoa beans typically fermented, dried, and ground at low temperatures.  This preserves more of the natural cocoa butter and flavanols but can result in a slightly more bitter taste compared to cocoa powder.

Crafting Chocolatey Flavor:

Both cocoa and cacao powder introduce the rich, complex flavor of chocolate to your shake. This flavor comes from several key components:

  • Cocoa Mass: This core ingredient is the ground-up cocoa bean, containing cocoa butter, cocoa solids, and flavonols. It provides the base chocolate flavor and contributes to the shake's texture.
  • Theobromine: This naturally occurring compound in cocoa beans offers a mild stimulant effect and contributes to the characteristic chocolate taste.
  • Flavor Precursors:  These are chemical compounds within the cocoa mass that, when broken down during processing, release volatile flavor components. These components contribute to the complex aroma and taste profile associated with chocolate.


Why choose unsweetened options? 

There are several reasons why people might choose unsweetened options for shakes and other beverages:

  • Sugar Control: This is a major reason for many people. Added sugars can significantly increase the calorie content of a beverage and contribute to health problems like obesity, diabetes, and heart disease.  Choosing unsweetened options allows for greater control over the amount of sugar you consume.
  • Dietary Needs:  People with diabetes, pre-diabetes, or other conditions that require them to monitor their sugar intake may specifically seek out unsweetened options. Additionally, those following low-carb or ketogenic diets often opt for unsweetened choices to stay within their daily carbohydrate limits.
  • Flavor Customization:  Unsweetened options offer a blank canvas for flavor exploration. You can add natural sweeteners like honey, maple syrup, or fruit to create a customized sweetness level without the additional sugars or artificial sweeteners that might be present in pre-sweetened products.
  • Ingredient Transparency:  Unsweetened options typically have a shorter ingredient list, allowing for easier identification of potential allergens or unwanted ingredients. This can be particularly important for people with sensitivities or those who prefer a more natural approach to their diet.
  • Versatility:  Unsweetened options can be used in both sweet and savory applications.  For shakes, you can add fruit or other flavorings to create a sweet beverage.  However, unsweetened options can also be used for protein shakes with minimal additional ingredients, or even incorporated into savory smoothies with vegetables and herbs.

While unsweetened options offer several benefits, it's important to consider your taste preferences and dietary needs. If you enjoy a sweeter taste, you can always add natural sweeteners to unsweetened options to achieve your desired level of sweetness.

Experiment with Extracts

Extracts offer a world of exciting flavor possibilities for your shakes, allowing you to create unique and nuanced taste experiences beyond the realm of basic fruits and yogurt. Here's a closer look at how mint, almond, and coconut extracts can elevate your shakes:

Mint Extract: A Refreshing and Invigorating Twist

Mint extract, derived from peppermint or spearmint leaves, offers a refreshingly cool and invigorating flavor profile. Here's how it enhances your shake:

  • Complementary Fruits:  Mint pairs beautifully with a variety of fruits, particularly berries like strawberries, raspberries, and blueberries. The cool mint cuts through the sweetness of the fruit, creating a refreshing and balanced taste experience.
  • Chocolate Creations:  A small amount of mint extract can add a delightful and unexpected twist to chocolate shakes. The mint complements the richness of the chocolate, creating a more complex and interesting flavor profile.  Think of the classic "Mint Chocolate Chip" flavor combination.
  • Energy Boost:  Mint is often associated with feelings of alertness and can add a refreshing and invigorating element to your shake, particularly for a post-workout beverage.

Using Mint Extract:

  • Start Low: Mint extract is quite potent. Begin with a very small amount, typically 1/8 teaspoon or less, and gradually increase to your desired level of mint intensity.
  • Fresh Herbs:  For a more subtle and natural mint flavor, consider adding a few fresh mint leaves to your shake along with other ingredients.

Almond Extract: A Nutty and Aromatic Touch

Almond extract, capturing the essence of almonds, introduces a nutty and aromatic flavor profile to your shakes. Here's how it elevates your taste experience:

  • Fruity Fusion:  Almond extract complements various fruits, particularly those with stone fruit characteristics like peaches, apricots, and cherries. The almond adds a subtle nutty depth, enhancing the natural sweetness of the fruit.
  • Vanilla Variations:  A small amount of almond extract can add a sophisticated twist to vanilla shakes. The almond complements the vanilla's sweetness, creating a more complex and interesting flavor profile.  Think of the classic flavor combination in wedding cake.
  • Creamy Delights:  Almond extract pairs beautifully with creamy ingredients like yogurt or nut butter.  This combination creates a rich and decadent-tasting shake.

Using Almond Extract:

  • Experiment with Dosage:  Almond extract has a moderate potency. Start with 1/4 teaspoon and adjust based on your desired level of almond flavor.
  • Real Almonds:  For a more intense and textural experience, consider adding a few chopped almonds to your shake alongside the almond extract.

Coconut Extract: A Tropical and Versatile Flavor

Coconut extract, capturing the essence of coconut, offers a tropical and versatile flavor profile for your shakes. Here's how it elevates your taste experience:

  • Tropical Paradise:  Coconut extract is a natural fit for creating tropical-inspired shakes.  Pair it with fruits like pineapple, mango, or banana for a taste of the islands.
  • Creamy Comfort:  Coconut extract adds a delightful depth of flavor to creamy shakes made with yogurt, coconut milk, or nut butter.  This combination creates a rich and comforting beverage.
  • Chocolate Combinations:  A small amount of coconut extract can add a subtle tropical twist to chocolate shakes. The coconut complements the richness of the chocolate, creating a more complex and interesting flavor profile.  Think of the popular "Almond Joy" candy bar flavor combination.

Using Coconut Extract:

  • Gradual Increase:  Coconut extract can be quite potent. Begin with a very small amount, typically 1/8 teaspoon or less, and gradually increase to your desired level of coconut flavor.
  • Real Coconut:  For a more intense coconut experience and added texture, consider incorporating shredded coconut or coconut flakes into your shake alongside the extract.


Combine with Frozen Vegetables

While fruits reign supreme as the classic ingredient in shakes, incorporating frozen vegetables offers a surprising and advantageous twist.  This seemingly unconventional addition unlocks a multitude of benefits, transforming your shake from a delightful beverage to a nutritional powerhouse.

A Nutritional Powerhouse:  Frozen vegetables boast a unique advantage.  Flash-frozen at their peak ripeness, they retain a remarkable amount of essential vitamins, minerals, and fiber.  This translates to a significant boost in the nutritional content of your shake compared to a purely fruit-based version.  Leafy greens like spinach and kale, for instance, are excellent sources of vitamins A, C, and K, alongside iron and folate.  These essential micronutrients contribute to a variety of bodily functions and overall health.

Subtle Flavor Integration: The beauty of frozen vegetables lies in their subtle flavor profile.  When blended with fruits and other ingredients, their taste becomes pleasantly restrained.  This allows you to seamlessly integrate extra nutrients without overpowering the overall flavor profile of your shake.  The subtle vegetal notes can even add a refreshing complexity to the fruit's sweetness.

Enhanced Texture and Satiety:  Beyond the nutritional boost, frozen vegetables add a delightful textural dimension to your shake.  Their presence creates a thicker consistency, making the shake more filling and satisfying.  This can be particularly beneficial if you're utilizing a low-calorie base like unsweetened almond milk.  The increased thickness contributes to a feeling of satiety, potentially aiding in appetite control.

Versatility and Exploration:  While leafy greens like spinach and kale are popular choices, the world of frozen vegetables offers a vast playground for exploration.  Consider experimenting with options like cauliflower, zucchini, or even beets for a touch of earthy sweetness.  Each vegetable offers a unique set of micronutrients and can subtly alter the flavor and texture of your shake, allowing for endless creative possibilities.

For those who struggle to consume enough vegetables, incorporating frozen greens into shakes presents a clever strategy.  The subtle flavor of frozen vegetables can be easily masked by fruits and other ingredients, making it a sneaky way to add essential nutrients to your diet.  This approach can be particularly helpful for children or individuals with aversions to vegetables.


Conclusion: Transforming Your Plant-Based Shakes

In conclusion, enhancing the flavor of your plant-based protein shakes is both feasible and enjoyable. By experimenting with ingredients like fruits, nut butter, spices, natural sweeteners, and extracts, you can create delicious and nutritious shakes tailored to your taste preferences and dietary needs. With a dash of creativity and a willingness to explore new flavors, you can turn your daily shake into a delightful treat that nourishes both body and soul.


Key Takeaways:

  • Elevate the taste of your plant-based protein shakes by incorporating ingredients like fruits, nut butter, spices, sweeteners, and extracts.
  • Experimenting with diverse ingredients not only improves flavor but also adds essential nutrients to your shakes, contributing to a healthier diet.
  • Customize your shakes according to your taste preferences, dietary restrictions, and fitness goals, ensuring that each shake suits your individual needs.
  • With a wide range of ingredients available, plant-based shakes offer ample opportunities for creative experimentation, allowing you to discover unique flavor combinations and textures.
  • Plant-based shakes provide a convenient and versatile option for boosting protein intake, whether as a post-workout refuel, quick breakfast, or satisfying snack throughout the day.
  • By enhancing the taste and nutritional content of your shakes, you can increase your enjoyment of these beverages while feeling satisfied and nourished with each sip.




You Might Also Like

Blog Categories


Tap our latest posts below to learn more. Follow @yeswellness for more inspiration.